FAI Cup Final Preview: Drogheda
United v Derry City
Drogheda
United FC v Derry City FC., FAI Cup Final, Aviva Stadium, Sunday 10th
November 2024, kick-off 3pm
Derry City’s 1-0 loss at home to Shelbourne last Friday saw
Damien Duff’s men lift their first title in eighteen years in the Brandywell, condemning
Derry City to a fourth placed finish. Four weeks ago, the Candystripes could
have gone top with two wins in their games in hand, but a late season injury
crisis and run of poor form has seen City finish outside of the automatic
European places for the first time since 2021. Sunday’s FAI Cup final is Derry
City’s second in three years, but the pressure is really on this time round. Ruaidhrí
Higgins’ men need to beat Drogheda United to play European football in 2025,
failure to do so would be disastrous. Drogheda haven’t been in an FAI Cup final
since 2013, when they lost 3-2 to Sligo Rovers, with their 2-0 victory in the
final in 2005 their last Cup triumph. They have an equally important relegation
play-off tie with Bray Wanderers in Tallaght Stadium next Saturday.
Last time out – Derry City 0-1 Shelbourne:
In a similar vain to last week, we don’t want to have to
relive Friday’s game again, so I’ll keep this recap short. Derry City would’ve
secured European football if St. Pat’s dropped points to Sligo Rovers and the
Candystripes won again Shelbourne. Shels brought a 300 strong, sold-out away support
in the hope that they’d watch their side lift a first title since 2006, having
only returned to the Premier Division in 2021. Both sides had an energetic
start, with Liam Burt’s low, driven effort being deflected wide by Duncan
Idehen within five minutes. City’s first real effort came 21 minutes in, when
Michael Duffy struck straight at Conor Kearns in the Shels goal. City’s number
seven again came close before the half-hour mark when he shot over following
his trademark move of cutting inside and aiming for the top corner. Derry’s
best opportunity of the half came ten minutes before the break, when Paul
McMullan fed Colm Whelan in the box. The former UCD man’s effort was scuffed
and easily dealt with – a better connection would’ve surely been an opener for
the Candystripes.
Within ten minutes of the second half beginning, City had
their best opportunity of the game. Ronan Boyce found space in the box after
beating Rayhaan Tulloch before putting an inch-perfect ball right onto the head
of Danny Mullen, who diverted his header onto the crossbar. A heart in mouth
moment for both sets of supporters. The aforementioned Tulloch came close on
the hour mark when he swept his effort wide of Brian Maher’s goal. Not long
after Sean Boyd missed a 1v1 with Brian Maher, the away side were denied what
seemed a clear penalty. Substitute Ali Coote burst into the box and was taken
down by the foot of Mark Connolly – huge shouts from the Shelbourne contingent
waived away by the referee. Just minutes later though, and Shelbourne had the
goal they craved. Jacob Davenport was adjudged to have handled the ball when it
flicked up into his mid-riff from close range. Sean Boyd fired the free kick,
which was right on the edge of the Derry box, low and to Brian Maher’s side.
The City keeper parried it as far as Harry Wood who knocked in from a
questionably offside position. With five minutes left, Shelbourne had found the
goal that would win them the league. The away end was in raptures and, despite
Wood chipping over the crossbar in stoppage time, Shels held on to claim the
first title won by a team not called ‘Shamrock Rovers’ since 2019.
Derry City:
There’s no denying that the end of the season was hugely
disappointing from a Derry City perspective. Less than a month ago, we had our
league title hopes in our hands and had a genuine shout at the double. Now,
though, we’ve stumbled to a fourth placed finish – outside of the European
spots. There were injury issues to key players towards the end of the season,
namely to Pat Hoban, Ciarán Coll, Ben Doherty and Patrick McEleney, but there
just didn’t seem to be the fight that’s required from a team hoping to win a
league. Derry City, despite finishing the season with the second best goal
difference in the league, had the joint highest amount of draws (13). That
means that Derry only won 38.9% of their league games, less than four wins from
every ten games. Our longest winning run in the league in 2024 was three,
compared to four in 2023 and six in 2022. Despite signing the league’s best
striker of recent times in Pat Hoban, who finished 2024 as the joint top scorer
alongside Waterford’s Pádraig Amond on fourteen, Derry scored nine league goals
less than last year’s tally. City kept the best defensive record in 2023,
conceding just 24. Seven more goals were conceded in 2024, owing to the loss of
Cameron McJannet and injury hit campaigns of Ben Doherty and Ciarán Coll.
On the other hand, Derry had the best disciplinary record in
the league, picking up 78 yellow cards. That’s fifty less than Shelbourne, who
were shown the most yellow cards with 128. (@StattoLOI on X). Not receiving
yellow cards doesn’t win you leagues though, and it just goes to show how being
a master of the dark arts can play into your advantage. Michael Duffy and Paul
McMullan finished joint fourth in the assist charts for the league, both making
five goals for teammates. Brandon Kavanagh, who City sold to St. Pat’s in
January, finished the season with thirteen assists – the most in the league.
Derry couldn’t promise him game-time, but having Kavanagh playing consistently
in that number 10 role this season could have won Derry the league. Brian Maher
was one of only three players in the Premier Division to play every single
minute, whilst McMullan made the joint most appearances for a foreign player with
36 – a real testament to the Scotsman’s fitness.
I’ve spoken about the contract situation of most of the
players in the squad recently, whilst we do need a refresh and I’d expect to
see quite a different team at the start of next season, there are some players
who we really need to try to keep hold of. Brian Maher was the only player who
remained on the pitch to applaud the fans on Friday night – he has been linked
to Shamrock Rovers in the past, but a new contract would be a major coup. Adam
O’Reilly’s rumoured move to St. Pat’s may now be off, as Stephen Kenny
persuaded holding midfielder Jamie Lennon to sign a new long-term contract
after being linked to clubs in America. Colm Whelan has been impressive since
returning from injury and is 100% fit for the first time as a Derry City
player, I’d hope for him to start the final on Sunday and sign a new deal at
the club. The pitch may put him off staying at the Brandywell though. Duncan
Idehen impressed on Friday night, he was confident in the air and calm on the
ball and recovered from a mistake in the box in the second half. Pat Hoban and
Partrick McEleney played no part on Friday night but may be fit enough to
feature in Sunday’s final. Cameron Dummigan, Ciarán Coll, Daniel Kelly and Ben
Doherty are all out.
Despite a poor league campaign, Derry City have shone in the
cup. Higgins’ men won all four games played, scoring eight and conceding none
in doing so. In fact, City haven’t conceded in open play in the FAI Cup since
Rory Gaffney scored for Shamrock Rovers in the quarter-final in 2022. The
performances against Shelbourne and St. Pat’s in the Brandywell were Derry’s
finest in 2024, whilst we dug deep away to Cork City and scored two brilliant
goals to put Bohemians to the sword in the semi-final. That away end in
Dalymount was one of the best I’ve seen in years and with well more than 38,000
tickets sold for the final on Sunday, I’d expect the Aviva to be rocking.
For reference, last year’s FAI Cup final between Bohemians
and St Pat’s saw an attendance of 43,881 – more than the KNVB Cup final in the
Netherlands between Feyenoord and NEC Nijmegen and just 3000 less than the Coupe
de France final between Lyon and PSG - big company for the LOI. There were 32,412
at Derry’s last final in 2022, with well over 20,000 of those Derry fans. Derry’s
previous final against St Pat’s in 2014 saw just 17,038 – what a rise in a decade,
truly brilliant to see.
Michael Duffy has been central to City’s cup hopes in 2024,
scoring four goals - both in the semi-final against Bohemians, the opener
against Shelbourne and the winner against St. Pat’s. Danny Mullen bagged a
brace against Pat’s and scored the winner against Shelbourne. The only other
man to score for Derry City in the FAI Cup in 2024 was Sam Todd, who headed
City to victory away in Cork. He’s recently started in the UEFA Conference
League for Larne, on-loan from City. Derry’s defence have been impenetrable in
cup action this year, something they will hope to carry on into the final. With
a place in UEFA Conference League qualifiers, and a possible seventh FAI Cup on
offer, you’d expect City to go all out for a win on Sunday. Using that big
pitch as an advantage, as we did in 2022 against Shelbourne, don’t be shocked
to see Paul McMullan stick tight to the touchline and for Derry to play mostly
on the wings to fashion chances. For the last time in 2024 we’ll see Derry City
in action. It's City's 1700th competitive game and it doesn’t get much bigger than this.
Route to the final:
Round 1: Bye
Round 2: Derry City 3-0 St. Patrick’s Athletic
Round 3: Cork City 0-1 Derry City
Quarter-final: Derry City 2-0 Shelbourne
Semi-final: Bohemians 0-2 Derry City
Drogheda United:
No matter which way Sunday goes, reaching the cup final and
avoiding automatic relegation for the Premier Division’s only part-time team is
some achievement. Tipped to go down before the season began, Drogheda United
have established themselves as something of a bogey team for many a Premier
Division side, owing to their hard-to-beat nature and tight Weaver’s Park
pitch. After defeat in the Brandywell on the opening day, the Louth side had a
rocky start to the season, with a 2-1 home win over Bohemians in early March coming
as their only win in the first ten games of the campaign. Included in those
first ten were five draws however, taking points of Derry City, St. Patrick’s
Athletic and eventual champions Shelbourne before going to pick up wins over
Sligo Rovers and Dundalk in spring. That aforementioned win at home to their
Louth rivals and fellow relegation contenders was Drogheda’s only league win
between the 6th of May and the 26th of July – a near
three month winless streak in league action.
The most impressive week of Drogheda United’s season came in
mid August. After hammering Munster Senior League side Wilton United 9-0 in the
FAI Cup, Drogheda put seven past a Sligo Rovers side who were pushing for
Europe. Sixteen goals without reply in two games showed that Kevin Doherty’s
men meant business going into the latter stages of the season. A strong
transfer window, which saw the loan signing of Douglas James-Taylor from
Walsall and the arrivals of Jad Hakiki and Aodh Dervin from Dundalk and
Shelbourne respectively showed that the club were strengthening well going into
the relegation scrap. Drogheda had a strong end to the season, losing just two
of their last seven, and taking the scalps of Derry City and Bohemians – inflicting
on the former a huge dent to their title hopes, and pulling the latter down
towards them in ninth position. It was ninth where Doherty’s men would end up –
not quite safe but eight points clear of their Louth rivals Dundalk at the foot
of the table. They face Bray Wanderers, a side who haven’t been in the Premier
Division since 2018, in the Play-Off final in Tallaght next Saturday – a winner
takes all tie which will close the curtain on the 2024 League of Ireland season.
A week after an emphatic beating of Bohemians in the
semi-final of the FAI Cup, Derry City travelled to Drogheda knowing that a win
would send Derry top of the Premier Division table. Compounding our misery on a
genuinely Baltic evening in southern county Louth, Frantz Pierrot struck twice
in eight minutes after the hour mark to sink the Candystripes. Looking back, it
wasn’t just a cataclysmic blow to City’s title hopes, but it’s given everyone
who watched that game a glimpse of the firepower of Pierrot and James-Taylor up
front. Both goals highlighted the same problem in Derry’s defence – Pierrot and
James-Taylor used their pace to get the better of Derry’s high-line, and the
lack of pace between Wisdom and Connolly. DJT and Pierrot are a classic front
two. James-Taylor is a lightning quick forward who plays on the shoulder of the
defender and has a real eye for goal, you don’t make 50 appearances in League
Two in your early 20s for nothing. Pierrot is a big target-man who is best when
backing into the centre back and throwing his weight around. The Haitian’s
positioning is another strong point of his game – his ten league goals tied him
in joint fourth with Sean Boyd of Shelbourne in the Premier Division scoring
charts. It also meant that he scored more goals than any other foreign player
in the league in 2024. Douglas James-Taylor and Frantz Pierrot have scored or
assisted 26 goals between them in league and cup action for Drogheda United
this year – a statistic even more impressive when you consider that
James-Taylor only arrived in July, and Pierrot had only four goals before their
partnership.
There is a bit of a reliance on the two big men up top for
Drogheda though – July departee left-back Evan Weir is tied with former Finn
Harps striker Adam Foley on four league goals in third place on Drogs’ scoring
charts. Foley’s brace off the bench to beat Wexford in the semi-final was his
second and third in the FAI Cup this season, though. His 92nd minute
winner shows that age isn’t an issue for the big striker who turns 35 next
month. Darragh Markey is one of the most underrated playmakers in the league
and wouldn’t look out of place playing higher up the table. The introduction of
the experienced Gary Deegan is a player in the centre of the park in recent
weeks following injury helped Drogheda stave of automatic relegation, at 37
he’s another level head in the United lineup. The energetic Shane Farrell was
an impressive signing from Shelbourne, whilst the arrival of full-back Elicha
Ahui, who spent half of the 2023 season at Drogheda, was another astute signing.
Former Finn Harps defender David Webster would, much like Adam Foley, love to
get one over his old side’s deepest rivals. Jack Keaney, UCD’s captain in 2023,
adds a versatile player to the defence, being comfortable operating in
defensive midfield or centre back. Andrew Wogan and Luke Dennison have
alternated in the goalkeeping department this year, with the latter keeping the
18 year old Wogan out of the lineup following an impressive start to life in
the League of Ireland for the young shot stopper.
In terms of FAI Cup action, Drogheda United, with 18 goals,
have scored more than anyone else in the competition this year – half of which
came in the Third Round drubbing of Wilton United. Douglas James-Taylor, with
six, is the competition’s top scorer – half of which, again, came as a
hat-trick in that win over Wilton. Michael Duffy is second in the FAI Cup
scoring charts, with four. On the contrary, Derry City are the only team with a
perfect defensive record in the cup this year – they’ve gone the whole way to
the final without conceding a single goal. In that sense, Sunday’s final ought
to be entertaining – the highest scoring v. the best defence. A cup win for
Drogheda United would be historic, they’ve lifted it just once and reached the
final only four times, but Kevin Doherty may have an eye on next week’s
play-off tie against Bray Wanderers. Would he, or the Drogheda fans, take a cup
win over relegation considering the financial implications of the latter? It’s
hard to know, but if they’re losing going into the last fifteen or so, Doherty
may roll the dice and rest some key men. A win on Sunday would have them running
on peak confidence going into the play-off, though. Drogheda United do have a
fully fit squad and were able to rotate against already relegated Dundalk in
the last game of the season. In that sense, they may have a fitness edge on the
Candystripes.
This one will be closer than you may expect and, with
Drogheda United selling out their allocation, a bumper crowd is to be expected.
United began their cup journey with a home win over rivals Dundalk, before
battering Wilton United in the Third Round. Athlone Town, at the time in great
form in the First Division, lost 4-1 at home to a ten man Drogheda United in
the quarters. Wexford, another First Division play-off hopeful, travelled to
Louth in the semis, losing 3-2. Doherty’s men have had something of a never say
die attitude in the cup this year, flexing their muscles against MSL and First
Division opposition and getting the better of their bitter, local rivals.
Similarly to Derry in 2022, Drogheda United have been drawn
as the home team in the tie but given the North Stand in the Aviva - usually
used to house away fans in Republic of Ireland fixtures. That may not be a bad
thing for Drogs, though - the team whose fans have been given that end have won
each of the last three finals. It’s only a coincidence, but aside from the
lockdown-hit 2020 final, Shamrock Rovers in 2019 were the last team to win the final
when their fans were given the bigger South Stand. Hoping for a first cup win
in nineteen years, and in only their fifth final in their history, Drogheda
United will be praying that fate is on their side and will certainly be up for
a fight come Sunday.
Route to the final:
Round 1: Bye
Round 2: Drogheda United 2-1 Dundalk
Round 3: Drogheda United 9-0 Wilton United
Quarter-final: Athlone Town 1-4 Drogheda United
Semi-final: Drogheda United 3-2 Wexford
Round-up:
Sunday’s FAI Cup typifies a tale of two seasons for Derry
City and Drogheda United. Derry City, pushing Shelbourne for top spot for most
of the season, have had a catastrophic end to the campaign which has seen them
drop to a fourth placed finish in the league. Shelbourne, Shamrock Rovers and
St. Patrick’s Athletic hold the European spots, meaning Derry City simply need
to win to have European football, and the finances that will bring, in 2025. A
loss would be disastrous, it’ll be harder to attract players and tougher to
finance the type of contracts that top League of Ireland players are on now
without the few hundred thousand cash injection that comes with UEFA Conference
League qualification football. Drogheda United, on the other hand, are in the
Aviva for the first time in eleven years, hoping to win only their second ever
FAI Cup. The pressure is off them, even finishing as runners-up would mark a
good season if they manage to stave of Bray Wanderers in the play-off. Kevin
Doherty will want his side to take momentum into that game, which is arguably
more important to their season than the cup final. Both Derry City and Drogheda
United have beaten each other in 2024, Derry 2-1 and 5-1 in the Brandywell, and
Drogs 2-1 in Weaver’s Park. With both teams representing the different
realities of football at the top and bottom of the Premier Division table, the
biggest day in the Irish footballing calendar is living up to its billing.
Pól O’Hare – 7th November 2024
That’s another season drawn to a close and I’m proud to say
that I’ve written a preview for every one of Derry City’s fixtures this season.
Whilst it hasn’t been the ending to the year that we hoped for, we have one
last day out before three months without League of Ireland football. I’d like
to thank everyone who has read, shared or interacted with my previews – it’s
much appreciated. Have a good Christmas and New Year folks, I’ll see you in
February. Up the City.