Derry City v St. Patrick’s Athletic: FAI Cup Match Preview

 

Derry City v St. Patrick’s Athletic: FAI Cup Match Preview

 

Derry City FC v St. Patrick’s Athletic FC, Sports Direct FAI Cup Second Round, Ryan McBride Brandywell Stadium, Sunday 21^st July 2024, kick-off 6pm

Derry City need to quickly forget about Thursday’s extra-time defeat to Bruno’s Magpies in the UEFA Conference League, as they aim to get their FAI Cup campaign off to a positive start against the holders. Evan de Haro’s extra-time sucker punch inflicted a blow on the Candystripes that will deny them around €300k and a double-header against FC Copenhagen. It also means that Ruaidhrí Higgins will have a fatigued squad going into Sunday’s cup game. St Patrick’s Athletic travel to the Brandywell for the second year in a row, hoping for a repeat of last August’s action which saw them knock Derry City out of the cup on penalties – just four days after City suffered the same fate in Europe.

Last time out: Derry City 2-0 Bruno’s Magpies (2-3 agg.):

It was a case of ‘so close yet so far’ for the Candystripes on Thursday night, as they crashed out of Europe at the first hurdle. Going into the game 2-0 down from the previous leg, Derry City had it all to do to qualify for the second round and face Danish giants FC Copenhagen.

The game started exactly as expected. Derry City began on the front-foot and Magpies immediately had everyone behind the ball. A couple of early opportunities for the away side saw Javier Forjan head one off the post and Ash Taylor head wide from a corner – but those were Magpies best opportunities of the first half. The first of a number of refereeing blunders took place as the City faithful celebrated what they thought was the first goal. Paul McMullan’s ball into the box was met by the head of Pat Hoban and directed into the bottom corner as he outmuscled Francisco Zuniga. The Magpies captain fell to the ground, before putting his hands to face in apparent discomfort just as he watched the ball nestle in the corner. The Andorran ref deemed Hoban’s header illegal, ruling out the goal and booking the City striker.

The deadlock was finally broken eight minutes later as Mark Connolly nodded Ben Doherty’s corner past Dayle Coleing to narrow the aggregate gap to one. The referee couldn’t stop Derry City’s goal this time. As the crowd rose to the occasion and Derry mounted  pressure late in the first half, Doherty found Adam O’Reilly who was making a darting run into the box. A trailing leg from Carlos Garcia saw O’Reilly downed in the area. Perhaps not a blatant penalty, but there was certainly contact between the two players. Not enough contact for the referee though, who showed the City midfielder a second yellow for diving – City inexplicably down to ten going into half-time.

Despite the man disadvantage, Derry again came out flying in the second half as Paul McMullan stung the fingertips of Coleing just a minute into the half. Twelve minutes after the restart and City found themselves level in the tie. After his header came off Will Patching on the goal-line, Pat Hoban stabbed in to put Derry 2-0 up in the Brandywell. Ten man City finally felt that the chance of progression was there. An audacious Will Patching free kick in the 72^nd minute had Coleing scrambling as the ball landed on top of the net. Six minutes later and Magpies should have really found themselves ahead on aggregate as Kevagn Ronco squared to Edu Salles in the box. The latter blazing over from short range. City found themselves in a similar situation just minutes later, as Paul McMullan had the whole goal to aim at following Danny Mullen’s pull-back but sent the ball flying wide.

2-0 City at 90 minutes meant that extra-time was needed to settle the tie. With tired legs in both camps, the rhythm of the game was disrupted and the affair became a scrappy one. There weren’t many clear cut chances in the first half of ET, but when Juanje’s shot from distance rattled the crossbar on the 111^th minute before landing at the feet of Evan de Haro, Magpies found themselves with a golden opportunity. The 21 year old made no mistake, drilling under Brian Maher and giving the away side the advantage once again. Three minutes later and City had another penalty claim waved away when Will Patching was felled after a volley goalwards. Another ‘no’ from the Andorran ref. City’s heartbreak was compounded five minutes before the end, when Coleing spilled the ball at the feet of Pat Hoban, who’s overhead kick was cleared off the line by Ash Taylor. Colm Whelan came painfully close with a volley in the 120^th minute, but the team from Gibraltar clung on and progressed for the first time in their history to host FC Copenhagen next Thursday.

 

Derry City:

It was a heartbreaking evening for Derry City who, on another day, could have had four or five in normal time alone. The disallowed goal and dismissal of Adam O’Reilly in the first half were two huge turning points, and both very dubious calls from the referee. The fact that Derry fought back to score again and take the game to extra-time despite being a man down, as well as dominating possession throughout, showed the resolve of the group. In honesty though, the damage was done in Gibraltar last week. If it was 1-0 rather than 2-0, I have no doubts that we would’ve gone through in the second leg.

Pat Hoban, who was well marshalled in the first leg, caused the Magpies back-line a lot of issues on Thursday night and was deserving of his goal. Paul McMullan ran and ran all game, still tracking back and making forward runs deep into extra-time. The winger really should have scored in the second half but was still the best player on the pitch. Colm Whelan was unlucky not to score late on, whilst Will Patching and Cameron Dummigan plugged the Adam O’Reilly shaped gap in the midfield well following the 23 year old’s red card.  

Neither Ciaron Harkin nor Ronan Boyce were in the squad for either of the games against Magpies, but I feel that they both could have done well last night. If Boyce was on the bench, he could have been brought on at right back to allow Cameron Dummigan to play in the midfield after the sending off. Ciaron Harkin’s tenacity would have boded well in extra-time, especially considering that Sadou Diallo was caught on the ball more than once after coming on late in the second half.

Ciarán Coll had a solid game playing as the left sided centre back, a role I’d like to see him given more-often between now and the end of the season. Even at that, though, we could still definitely do with another defender to replace Cameron McJannet. McJannet’s last game was on the 13^th of June, five weeks ago, and he is still yet to be replaced. Jacob Davenport, our only summer signing, has yet to feature despite being on the bench twice. His fresh legs and set-piece ability could have been useful against Magpies. I’d say we’ll see him on Sunday against St.Pat’s. Should we beat Pat’s, we would certainly need reinforcements to strengthen the squad coming into the second half of the season. The contracts of a number of key players, namely Adam O’Reilly, Brian Maher, Will Patching, Mark Connolly and Patrick McEleney run out in November. I’d hope that talks are ongoing in the background, and don’t blame the players for assessing their options, but it’s concerning that we could lose our best and most valuable players on free transfers in a few months’ time.

St Patrick’s Athletic:

St Pat’s have had quite the up-and-down season. After spending big and making some impressive moves in the transfer market prior to the season beginning, the Inchicore side have failed to nail down a consistent run of form in the league. Now Dundalk manager Jon Daly was sacked in May and replaced by Stephen Kenny in one of the biggest managerial appointments in Irish domestic football history. The man who won six trophies with Derry City in two spells between 2004 and 2011 made his return to the League of Ireland after a five-and-a-half year hiatus with the Irish U21s then senior men’s national team, in a home match against the Candystripes on the 17^th of May. Paul McMullan’s goal gave the visitors all three points that day, as the ‘new manager bounce’ didn’t quite go to plan for the Pat’s faithful.

Stephen Kenny has only won three matches since taken over in Richmond Park, beating Shamrock Rovers and Galway United in the league, alongside a win over Bray Wanderers in the Leinster Senior Cup. St Patrick’s find themselves seventh in the league, six points above the relegation zone but, much like Derry City, the sides around them have the advantage of games in hand. Only Pat’s and Derry have played 25 games this season. Bohemians, who are one place and two points behind St. Pat’s have played just 22, meaning they have a three game buffer on the team above them. Finding themselves embroiled in a relegation scrap at this stage of the season would signal quite the failure in expectation for Pat’s this season.

The FAI Cup, which Kenny has won three times and been runner up four times, offers the Dubliner and his side something of a blank canvas to get their season back on track. After beating Derry on penalties in the Brandywell in the Third Round last year, St. Pat’s progressed past Finn Harps and Cork City on their way to sweeping Dublin rivals Bohemians aside in the final. Last year’s 3-1 final win marked Pat’s’ second FAI Cup win in three seasons as they beat Bohemians again in 2021. That win in 2021 was their first FAI Cup triumph since defeating Derry City 2-0 in the 2014 edition of the final, and that was their first FAI Cup final win since 1961. A win against the Candystripes in the Second Round this year would be the beginning of what Stephen Kenny would hope to be a successful FAI Cup campaign but would also mean that Derry City have failed to progress past the Third Round since winning the trophy in 2022.

Pat’s three summer signings so far seem to be shrewd business. Al-Amin Kazeem, the full back who was on loan at Galway United from Colchester United, saw his contract with the English side expire alongside his loan deal in Galway. The Tribesmen made it known that they offered Kazeem a permanent contract which was declined as the player wanted to return to England. A few days later and the 22 year old was announced as a St Patrick’s Athletic player on a multi-year contract –ouch if you’re a Galway United fan. Joseph Anang, the English goalkeeper who spent half a season on-loan at St Pat’s in 2022 before leaving for Derby County, was the Saints’ second summer arrival. The 24 year old, who was named on the West Ham United bench on numerous occasions in the Premier League, Europa League and FAI Cup in the past few seasons in West London put pen to paper on a deal keeping him at Richmond Park until the end of the 2026 campaign. Anang came straight into the starting eleven in Pat’s’ last game, a 1-0 loss away to Waterford, ousting fellow Englishman Danny Rogers who held the fort between the sticks since early March. On his first start in two years for the Saints, Anang failed to deal with Ben McCormack’s shot and palmed the ball into his own net for the only goal of the game, but his performances in 2022 show the makings of a quality goalkeeper. Zack Elbouzedi, formerly of Waterford and Ireland’s U21 side, signed just last week and could make his debut on Sunday. The 26 year old winger spent the second half of last season on-loan at Swindon Town from AIK Stockholm, where he scored twice in 52 appearances since 2021. Another impressive addition to the squad in Inchicore.

Former Derry City and Shamrock Rovers midfielder Brandon Kavanagh, who was signed from the Candystripes for about £25k in January, has been Pat’s best attacking outlet this year. The 23 year old has scored twice and assisted seven in the league, seeing him top the assist chart for the Premier Division. Ruairí Keating, brought in from Cork City, has scored just four times in 22 appearances this campaign. 16 year old forward Mason Melia is one to watch though – the Ireland U17 international has scored three times this season and is reportedly a target of Manchester City, Arsenal and Brighton. St. Patrick’s Athletic have struggled in front of goal this season though. Their 24 goals scored is the same amount scored by bottom side Drogheda United. Only three other sides, Dundalk, Bohemians and Galway, have scored less this season. That isn’t helped when you look at Pat’s’ goals conceded column, which reads 28 – a stat which means they’ve conceded the joint highest number of goals outside of the two teams in the relegation zone.

When Derry City face St. Patrick’s Athletic on Sunday, the away side won’t have played a competitive game in more than three weeks as their FAI Cup final win last year saw them progress straight into the Second Round of Conference League qualifiers. They’ll face Vaduz, who finished third in the Liechtenstein Challenge League last season, at home next Thursday before travelling away the week after. The Inchicore side, therefore, will be fresh coming into Sunday’s game – something which can’t be said for Derry City, who are just off the back of more than 270 minutes of football in a week against FC Bruno’s Magpies.

Round-up:

These two have produced some memorable cup moments over the years. Pat’s’ win last season marked a week in which Derry City’s cup and European dreams were ended, both in penalty defeats, in a space of four days. Higgins and his side will be heart-set on making sure history can’t repeat itself. Back in 2018, Gerard Doherty saved a penalty with the last kick of the game to send Derry City to the quarter-finals, whilst Derry City beat Pat’s in the final in 2012 before the Inchicore side got their own back in 2014. The 2006 final beaten the Candystripes and the Saints has been dubbed the best FAI Cup final of all time, as Derry won the game in extra-time after going behind three times to win in the last ever match played in the old Lansdowne Road.

There’s history between these two, but Derry have claimed the bragging rights in the four occasions these two have met since that penalty defeat last year, namely beating Pat’s 3-0 on the final day of the 2023 campaign and scoring a 92nd minute winner to win 2-1 back in March. Danny Mullen has scored three times against the Inchicore side already this season. With Shamrock Rovers and Dundalk both put out on Friday night, both City and Pats will fancy their chances to go all the way. Cup football is back for 2024, as the winners of the last two editions go head-to-head at the first time of asking this time round. It’s good, old-fashioned Sunday evening football as both sides look to begin their cup campaigns with a win.

Pól O’Hare – 20^th July 2024

Derry City v Bruno’s Magpies: Match Preview

 

Derry City v Bruno’s Magpies: Match Preview

 

Derry City FC v. FC Bruno’s Magpies, UEFA Conference League, First Round Second Leg, Ryan McBride Brandywell Stadium, 18^th July 2024, kick-off 7.45pm

In a result that some have called the ‘worst in League of Ireland European history’, Derry City fell to a 2-0 defeat at the hands of FC Bruno’s Magpies in Gibraltar. The Candystripes were outdone by two headers from set-pieces in the second half as they struggled to put their opponents to the sword in 30C+ heat. City now need to win by a margin of at least three goals on Thursday to progress to a Second Round glamour tie against FC Copenhagen.

 

Last time out – Bruno’s Magpies 2-0 Derry City:

In a hot Europa Point Stadium, Derry City failed to make their mark as they faced opposition from Gibraltar for the first time. Bruno’s Magpies, who have never progressed passed the First Round of European qualifying, netted from two set pieces in the second half as Derry’s recent defensive frailties were once again brought to the fore.

The game didn’t start too badly. Adam O’Reilly had struck the crossbar within the first ten minutes, whilst a Dan Kelly effort which went under goalkeeper Dayle Coleing was cleared off the line. As the half wore on, the away side seemed to struggle in the sun and the home side grew into the game. 

Just four minutes after the restart, the deadlock was broken. After a poor pass across the backline by Paul McMullan, Javier Forjan picked the ball up before forcing Brian Maher into a finger-tip save to deny the Spanish striker. The resulting corner was met by Welsh defender Ash Taylor who rose above Shane McEleney at the back-post to nod past Maher, bagging himself a debut goal and putting his side into the lead. Less than ten minutes later, English forward Jack Storer took it past both Derry centre-halves in the box before firing over from 12 yards – that really should have doubled Magpies’ advantage. That eventually did happen on the 82^nd minute. Another floating ball in from a free kick was met by Francisco Zuñiga who put the game to bed. An awful result for the Candystripes, especially considering the efforts made by the 250 travelling supporters who made their way to the Europa Point Stadium, and the dozens more who travelled to Gibraltar. Next week needs to be much better if Derry City are to progress.

 

Derry City:

Derry City’s lack of clinical edge cost them last week. Dan Kelly found joy running in behind the Magpies left back and could have had two for himself with a bit more accuracy in his finishing. In saying that, Pat Hoban was well marshalled by Taylor and Zuñiga in the Magpies backline and had no clear cut opportunities. Will Patching was unlucky that his neat footwork didn’t result in an assist throughout the match as well.

As was our downfall against Sligo Rovers two weeks ago, the lapses in concentration from Derry’s defenders cost two goals in Gibraltar. To concede two from set pieces with two centre halves as usually aerially dominant as Mark Connolly and Shane McEleney will have been extremely disappointing for Ruaidhrí Higgins. I wouldn’t be surprised to see Sam Todd or Ciarán Coll start on Thursday in order to have a left-footed centre back in the starting eleven to fill the gap left by the departure of Cameron McJannet earlier in the summer. The sooner we replace the English defender the better, as a solid defence will be key between now and the end of the season.

We really have nothing to lose on Thursday. We’ve already received stick from all quarters of Irish football after the loss last week, so playing cautious and failing to go all-out-attack in the Brandywell won’t do us any favours. If I was Ruaidhrí Higgins I’d go for a good old-fashioned 4-4-2, with Danny Mullen partnering Pat Hoban up top, before introducing Colm Whelan from the bench. Starting that way would mean sacrificing a centre midfielder, but if we were to go 2-0 up relatively early on, the introduction of Sadou Diallo or Jacob Davenport from the bench would sure up the midfield. Michael Duffy, if he’s fit, would likely start, whilst Daniel Kelly may be preferred to Paul McMullan on the right flank after the Dubliner found himself in good positions last week. The big Brandywell pitch, and lack of sun, will favour Derry, but Magpies will likely put everyone behind the ball and make it extremely difficult for City to break them down. It’ll be a nervy watch, but a rocking Brandywell could get us over the line, as it did with KuPS and HB Tórshavn last year.

 

Bruno’s Magpies:

It seemed like Bruno’s Magpies had a gameplan against City last week, and it worked. Solid at the back and a threat from set pieces. Their physicality in the defence kept Pat Hoban quiet whilst they were dangerous playing in from the wings. Jack Storer really should’ve scored, whilst Javier Forjan and Carlos Garcia looked impressive pulling the strings. The team from Gibraltar will likely have the same approach next week, setting up a strong, physical back-line and holding on to their two goal lead. They know that just one goal in the Brandywell will probably send them through, as City would then need four to progress.

Despite being part-time, Magpies have players who came through the ranks at well respected LaLiga sides, and players with experience in England and Scotland. Lincoln Red Imps, Gibraltar’s most successful team with 27 league titles, beat Celtic in Champions League qualifiers in 2016-17. They also beat Riga in the Conference League play-offs in 2021-22 to progress the group stages. Derry City really *should* be getting past Magpies on paper, but this is a team with international players and a point to prove – a team who deserve to be respected, something Derry may not have fully done last Thursday.

Magpies made it difficult in their home legs against Crusaders and Dundalk in the past two years. They beat Crusaders and held Dundalk to a scoreless draw in Gibraltar, so they definitely knew that they could play their own game with the sun on their side. Magpies lost both of the return legs against Crusaders and Dundalk 3-1, showing that the sides from Ireland had more joy in their own stadiums. A 3-1 win for Derry would take the game to extra-time, something which would be nerve-wracking but could prove vital in clawing back the tie. Magpies are also in pre-season, so extra-time would likely the suit the Candystripes who, in theory, should be at their fittest stage of the campaign. It won’t be straight-forward at all next week but both teams will have sussed each other out a bit more and it may prove to be a more expansive match. The last time Derry City overturned a two goal deficit in Europe was 59 years ago, when they beat Lyn Oslo 5-1 in the Brandywell after losing the first leg 5-3. That win just happened to be City’s first in European competition.

Round-up:

Last Thursday’s result was very tough to take, there’s no doubt about it, but turning round a 2-0 goal deficit isn’t impossible. An early goal for City would open the tie up, whilst we can play with the Brandywell atmosphere on our side. That atmosphere after scoring against KuPS last season is the best I’ve seen here in years and could prove pivotal in getting a result. A trip to Copenhagen would be huge for both sides, and is surely an attractive prospect for the players. To throw in the towel and let Magpies have the win without putting up a fight would be a disaster, so we should at least set out fighting from the start. It’s St. Pat’s in the cup on Sunday after this, and we don’t want our European and Cup aspirations for the season going up in smoke in the space of four days like it did in 2023. A big win on Thursday could do wonders for our season, but it won’t come easy.

 

Pól O’Hare – 16^TH July 2024